Templars Vs. Assassins: The Real Difference

Templars Vs. Assassins: The Real Difference

Countless secret societies and groups have been imagined, speculated upon, and chronicled throughout history. Two names often stand out: the Templars and the Assassins. This article delves into the history and facts surrounding these enigmatic entities. Stay tuned! 

Were Assassins and Templars Real?

Let’s begin by acknowledging that the Assassins and the Templars were real historical entities. The Assassins referred to the Nizari Ismailis, a group of Shia Muslims that became notorious during the Middle Ages for their tactics involving political assassination. On the other hand, the Knights Templar was a medieval Christian military order renowned for their involvement in the Crusades.

The Templars and Assassins: Real History

The Assassins

The Nizari Ismailis, or “Assassins,” emerged during the 11th century in Persia and Syria. The term “Assassin” comes from “Hashashin,” which means “users of hashish,” although this is a point of historical contention. These individuals were highly trained in the arts of espionage and covert murder, targeting religious and political figures who they considered threats to their community. Their tactics brought them both fear and respect, making them a significant power in the Middle Eastern regions they inhabited.

The Templars

The Knights Templar, founded around 1119 CE, was primarily a religious military order. They initially provided protection for Christian pilgrims journeying to the Holy Land during the time of the Crusades. As they grew in power and wealth, the Templars also engaged in various financial endeavors, effectively operating as an early form of the banking system. However, their influence waned after the fall of the Crusader States, and they were disbanded under the command of Pope Clement V in 1312.

Templars Vs. Assassins: The Contrast

Despite their overlapping timelines, the Assassins and Templars were very different entities in their structure, purpose, and methods. With their Christian ideologies, military might, and economic power, the Templars sought to protect and expand Christian influence in the Holy Land. On the other hand, the Assassins were primarily a political and religious faction, using stealth, cunning, and targeted killings to maintain their power and influence.

While the Templars were more organized and operated like a formal military and religious order, the Assassins functioned more like a secret society, carrying out covert missions and relying heavily on the element of surprise. Their methods, though distinct, earned both groups a significant place in history.

Were the Assassins and Templars Enemies?

The narrative of the Assassins and Templars being sworn enemies is a compelling tale, often popularized by various forms of media, including video games like the ‘Assassin’s Creed’ series. Yet, historical evidence suggests a different scenario.

The Assassins (Nizari Ismailis) and the Knights Templar did coexist during the Middle Ages, but there is no concrete historical evidence to substantiate a direct, systematic conflict between the two. The Templars were primarily located in Western Europe and the Holy Land, while the Assassins operated mainly in Persia and Syria. Although their geographical territories did occasionally overlap, their objectives were markedly different.

The Assassins were predominantly concerned with maintaining their political and religious autonomy, often utilizing assassinations to eliminate threats to their survival. Meanwhile, the Templars were a military order with a focus on protecting Christian pilgrims and territories during the Crusades.

Furthermore, the historical accounts of the time do not detail significant confrontations between the two groups. In fact, there are instances where they might have interacted diplomatically due to their mutual interest in maintaining relative peace in their areas of influence. Therefore, while they operated in similar timeframes and geographical regions, the notion of the Assassins and Templars as bitter adversaries is more fiction than fact.

Did the Assassins Fight the Templars?

Contrary to popular belief inspired by modern media portrayals, there is no substantial historical evidence to suggest that the Assassins and the Templars directly engaged in combat against one another. While both groups existed during the same historical period of the Middle Ages, their missions, ideologies, and geographical territories were significantly distinct.

The Assassins, or the Nizari Ismailis, primarily operated in Persia and Syria, employing subterfuge and targeted killings to preserve their political and religious independence. Meanwhile, the Knights Templar, established as a Christian military order, were predominantly active in Western Europe and the Holy Land. Their primary aim was to safeguard Christian pilgrims and territories during the Crusades.

The primary sources of the time do not chronicle any grand battles or conflicts between these two groups. It is also worth noting that their different spheres of influence and differing objectives would have made direct conflict unlikely.

It’s plausible that they may have encountered each other during the volatile period of the Crusades. However, any notion of a systemic, centuries-long conflict between the Assassins and Templars is more a product of fiction and popular culture than historical reality.

Were the Assassins Stronger Than Templars?

Measuring the strength of the Assassins and the Templars involves complex analysis, as “strength” can be defined in various ways: military might, political influence, financial power, or even cultural impact. Moreover, both groups operated under different socio-political contexts and utilized different strategies to achieve their objectives.

The Templars likely held an edge in terms of military might and financial resources. As a military order endorsed by the Catholic Church, they amassed considerable wealth and robust infrastructure, including commanderies across Europe and the Middle East. Additionally, they were recognized for their discipline and combat prowess during the Crusades.

The Assassins, however, exerted influence through different means. As a relatively smaller sect, they mastered the art of deception and covert operations, earning an intimidating reputation. Their strength lay in their ability to influence politics through the strategic and targeted elimination of key figures.

Thus, it would be misleading to declare one group categorically stronger than the other. Each utilized its unique strengths within its context effectively. It’s important to remember that the Assassins and Templars were distinct entities with differing ideologies, strategies, and goals, making direct comparisons challenging.

Templars or Assassins: The Contemporary Discourse

The contemporary cultural image of the Assassins and Templars, heavily influenced by popular media and works like the ‘Assassin’s Creed’ video game series, often paints a rather dramatic picture of an ancient, ongoing conflict between the two groups. Still, this perception strays from historical facts. In reality, there is no recorded history of the Templars and Assassins fighting each other directly, and their goals and regions of influence did not significantly overlap.

Do Assassins and Templars Still Exist?

While the original historical entities of the Assassins and Templars no longer exist, their legacies continue in various forms.

The spiritual successors of the Nizari Ismailis, the Assassins, exist today as a sub-sect of Shia Islam led by the Aga Khan. While they have no connection to the tactics of assassination or political subversion associated with their medieval predecessors, they carry forward the sect’s philosophical and religious teachings.

The Templars, in contrast, were officially disbanded, and no direct continuation of the order exists. Nevertheless, various organizations claim to be inspired by or descended from the Templars. None of these, however, have a confirmed historical connection to the original order.

Final Words

In conclusion, the Assassins and Templars were real historical groups with distinct beliefs, methods, and impacts on history. While their original forms do not exist today, their legacies continue to influence religious, historical, and even pop-cultural discourse. Understanding the real differences between these groups enriches our understanding of the complexity and diversity of medieval history.